For over three years, the typical American residence consistently sold at higher prices than the previous year. That trend has now come to an end. October's national data reveal that the median sale price for homes has dropped slightly below where it was a year ago, marking the first year-over-year decrease since spring 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes for sale has reached its peak since early 2020, pending sales have fallen to levels not observed in over a decade outside the onset of the pandemic, and roughly one in five listings has experienced a price reduction.
However, there's a twist: borrowing has become pricier again. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range over the past week after a brief period of decline. Therefore, even as buyers are gaining some negotiating advantage, monthly payments remain a challenge for many households.
This unique situation creates an interesting dynamic. Sellers are receiving fewer offers and homes are taking longer to sell, indicating that the listed price and terms are increasingly negotiable rather than set in stone. If you are in the market for a home this winter, consider what aspects may be negotiable, and how to strategize this with your real estate agent and lender.
A national dip of less than half a percent does not signify a market collapse, nor does it imply that prices are declining everywhere. Some high-priced coastal areas with limited inventory are still experiencing notable price increases, while various major metropolitan regions in the South and West have seen several percentage points lost compared to last year. Your local market conditions outweigh national trends significantly.
The national figures suggest a shift in negotiating power. When homes linger on the market and many listings are vying for a smaller pool of buyers, sellers are becoming more amenable to negotiation. This newfound flexibility can affect pricing but also significantly influence the terms of the sale.
Many buyers tend to concentrate solely on the purchase price, but in a high-interest-rate climate, the implications of monthly payments and closing cash required are often more important. A reduction of a few thousand dollars off the listed price may result in only a slight decrease in your loan payments. Alternatively, utilizing that same money differently can sometimes yield greater benefits for your financial situation. Here are common elements buyers may negotiate in a slower market:
Your real estate agent has insight into how local sellers are likely to respond and can assist you in determining which aspects to prioritize in your offer. The aim should not be to demand everything, but rather to ask for what will have the most significant positive effect on your purchase.
Closing expenses generally account for several percent of the total loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, gathering the necessary funds for these costs can be the most daunting aspect of the home-buying process. A seller credit can alleviate some of these expenses directly, allowing you to bring less to the closing table.
It is crucial to understand the limitations that exist. Different loan programs set caps on how much a seller is permitted to contribute, typically falling between 3% and 9% of the home's price depending on the mortgage type and your down payment size. Additionally, the credit granted usually cannot exceed your closing costs. Consult your lender early on to determine what your specific loan terms allow, ensuring that any requests made in your offer comply with those regulations.
Given that mortgage rates have risen above 7%, one excellent option a seller might offer is assistance with your interest rate. Two common approaches exist.
A permanent buydown involves purchasing discount points to reduce your interest rate for the lifetime of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, and how much the rate decreases can differ based on the lender and market conditions. If you intend to maintain the loan for several years, a permanent buydown could be a wise investment.
A temporary buydown reduces your payment during the initial years. A typical structure could involve the rate being two percentage points lower in the first year and one percentage point lower in the second year, before returning to the original rate. For instance, on a $350,000 loan with a 30-year term at approximately 7.34%, monthly principal and interest payments would be roughly $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the payment could drop to around $1,952 in the first year, followed by about $2,176 in the second year, and then return to the full payment in the third year. Funding this arrangement might exceed $8,000, which a seller may agree to rather than lowering the price by a similar amount.
However, a temporary buydown is not a permanent solution. You must still manage the full payment after the discount period concludes, and lenders usually qualify you at that higher rate. If rates drop in the future, refinancing might become an option, yet it is impossible to guarantee timing or feasibility.
In a heated market, many buyers waived inspections or limited their requests to secure a winning bid. In a more relaxed market, there's less urgency to forego those protections. A comprehensive home inspection enables you to assess the condition of crucial elements such as the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation prior to making a commitment.
If the inspection reveals issues, your agent can advise you on whether to seek repairs, negotiate a price adjustment, or request a credit. Credits often simplify the process compared to having sellers manage repairs, as you can choose how the work is executed, though the best option will depend on the situation and your loan requirements.
Having negotiating leverage means little if your financial situation is uncertain. A seller reviewing multiple offers will generally favor the buyer who appears most likely to finalize the deal. Before diving into serious house hunting, obtain a comprehensive preapproval in place of a rapid prequalification. Understanding your comfortable monthly payment is also crucial, not just your maximum loan amount. Compare loan estimates from various lenders and inquire how they would manage a seller credit or buydown to avoid unexpected issues later.
While a softer market does not equate to cheap buying opportunities, particularly with the rise in mortgage rates, it does provide prepared buyers with greater flexibility to negotiate favorable terms. With solid financial planning, a clear understanding of your priorities, and guidance from both your agent and lender, you may be able to secure terms that were unimaginable just a year or two ago.
Rewritten using AI
Whether you're buying your first home or upgrading to your forever one, we're here to guide you with expert advice and personalized service.